Buck's hearing he was asked by Commissioner Landis if he had sat in on any meetings to throw the 1919 World Series. Buck stated "Yes, Judge, I attended two such meetings, but I took no money." Landis responded: "Buck, you can't play ball with us again." With that, his request was denied. Buck Weaver would apply for reinstatement on five more occassions throughout his lifetime. Each request would be denied.
Throughout the first five years of his banishment however, Buck exercised daily to stay in shape for the day he would return to the big leagues. "I'll play for nothing" Buck once told a reporter. Unable to curb his thirst any longer, Buck returned to the baseball diamond playing Semi-Pro ball across the country from 1924 through 1931. In 1924 it was Sauk County, Wisconsin. In 1926 Douglas, Arizona followed by Hammond, Indiana in 1927. In 1928 and again 1931, Buck played in Illinois, in front of the old crowds of Chicago.
Buck became the manager of a girls softball team, the Bidwell Bluebirds in 1944 and also managed Charles Krutckoff's semi-pro Chicago team in 1947. Buck also worked as a florist for Mr. Krutckoff before working his final job as a clerk at the Parimutual Department of Chicago's Racetracks.
Although Buck Weaver and his wife, Helen, never had any children of their own, they helped raise two neices, Betty Scanlan and Patricia Anderson. On Janurary 31,1956, while walking to his income tax consultants office, Buck Weaver collapsed in the 1200 Block of West 71st Street and died of a heart attack.
In the early 1990's attorney Louis Hegemand along with two Federal Judges representing the late Buck Weaver submitted a 14 page memorandum to baseball Comissioner Fay Vincent requesting Buck's reinstatement. Their request was denied.
On July 15,2003 the Chicago White Sox hosted Major League Baseball's annual All-Star Game. Before the game, two members of Buck Weaver's family held a "Reinstate Buck Weaver" rally which took place on 35th and Shields, near the area of the original Comiskey Park third base. While Major League Baseball did not make any comments publicly on the rally, baseball Commissioner Bud Selig stated he would take another look into the matter of reinstating Buck Weaver.